The Science Behind Self-Regulation Struggles

by Jon Scaccia March 25, 2025

It was the middle of the school day when a fifth grader named Alex had his third meltdown of the week. His teacher, exhausted but compassionate, knelt beside him and asked what was wrong. “I don’t know,” he whispered through tears. “I just can’t handle it.” This wasn’t an isolated case. Across the country, children like Alex are struggling with anxiety, stress, and emotional regulation—but too often, their distress is dismissed as misbehavior.

Why do so many kids struggle to manage their emotions?

Research in child psychology and neuroscience shows that self-regulation—the ability to manage impulses, emotions, and behaviors—depends on brain development, environmental support, and learned skills.

A landmark study from the Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University found that self-regulation is like a muscle: it strengthens with practice but weakens under chronic stress. The problem? Modern school environments often overload kids’ stress systems without providing enough support.

Increased academic pressure, decreased recess time, and the pervasive influence of digital devices have created a perfect storm. According to a 2023 study in the Journal of School Psychology, children who get less than 30 minutes of free play during school hours show higher levels of cortisol. This stress hormone directly impacts their ability to concentrate and manage emotions.

Screens, Sleep, and School Stress: The Triple Threat to Mental Health

Ask any teacher about the biggest changes in student behavior over the past decade, and they’ll likely mention increased distractibility and emotional outbursts. What’s behind this shift? Research points to three major culprits:

• Screen Time Overload: A 2022 study in Pediatrics found that kids who spend more than two hours daily on screens show increased rates of anxiety and depression. Excessive screen use—especially before bed—disrupts sleep patterns and reduces deep rest, impairing emotional regulation.
• Chronic Sleep Deprivation: The American Academy of Pediatrics reports that 73% of teens don’t get enough sleep on school nights. Poor sleep isn’t just about being tired—it disrupts executive function, making it harder for kids to plan, focus, and regulate emotions.
• Academic Pressure & Social Anxiety: With standardized testing, packed schedules, and increased social comparison (thanks, social media!), students face relentless pressure. The result? A surge in school-related anxiety and avoidance behaviors.

The Power of Schools to Shape Resilience

While the challenges are significant, research offers hope. Schools can be a protective buffer against mental health struggles when they integrate three simple but powerful strategies:

1. Prioritizing Emotional Literacy

Teaching kids how to name and manage emotions can transform their ability to cope with stress. A 2023 meta-analysis in Child Development found that schools implementing social-emotional learning (SEL) programs saw a 27% decrease in student anxiety and depression. Schools can integrate SEL by:

• Starting the day with emotion check-ins.
• Teaching mindfulness and breathing techniques.
• Using calming corners instead of punitive time-outs.

2. Rethinking Recess and Movement

Recess is not just a break—it’s a mental reset. A recent study from the CDC found that children who have at least 60 minutes of physical activity per day show improved attention and lower stress levels. Yet, some schools cut recess for more instructional time—despite evidence that more movement actually improves academic performance.

A simple fix? Schools should:

• Implement short movement breaks between lessons.
• Ensure daily recess is non-negotiable.
• Allow for flexible seating (like standing desks) to accommodate fidgety learners.

3. Building Trauma-Sensitive Classrooms

For kids dealing with chronic stress or trauma, traditional discipline approaches often backfire. Instead of punishing “bad behavior,” educators should ask: What is this behavior communicating?

Schools that embrace trauma-informed practices see fewer behavior incidents and higher engagement. Strategies include:

• Using predictable routines to reduce anxiety.
• Training teachers in de-escalation techniques.
• Encouraging strong teacher-student relationships—even one supportive adult can change a child’s life trajectory.

What Parents Can Do Right Now

If you’re a parent wondering how to support your child’s mental health, start with these science-backed steps:

• Limit pre-bedtime screen time to improve sleep quality.
• Encourage unstructured play to boost emotional resilience.
• Talk openly about emotions—modeling emotional regulation helps kids develop their own coping strategies.
• Advocate for mental health-friendly school policies—join the PTA, email school leaders, and push for SEL and recess initiatives.

Let’s Talk About It

Children’s mental health is everyone’s responsibility. We need schools, families, and communities working together to create environments where kids can thrive.

💬 What’s the biggest mental health challenge you see in schools today? 💬 How can schools better support students’ emotional well-being? 💬 What’s one insight from school psychology that changed the way you parent or teach?

Drop a comment below, share this with fellow educators and parents, and let’s keep the conversation going. Together, we can build a world where every child feels safe, supported, and mentally strong.

Transform Education—Your Support Matters!

Join the movement with This Week in School Psychology—just $5/month or $50/year. We are entirely self-funded; your subscription directly sustains our delivery of groundbreaking insights on education and mental health. Be the expert your community needs in these challenging times. Subscribe now and secure the future of informed education!