How Early Childhood Screen Time Might Be Fueling Your Child’s Anger

by Jon Scaccia August 26, 2024

Imagine this: it’s been a long day, and your three-year-old is on the brink of another meltdown. You hand them a tablet, hoping it will keep them occupied long enough for you to finish making dinner or catch your breath. But what if that very tablet is quietly sowing the seeds for even more frustration and anger down the road?

A recent study published in JAMA has shed light on a concerning link between early childhood tablet use and increased expressions of anger and frustration as children grow older. The findings suggest that rather than being a harmless distraction, tablets might be contributing to a cycle that undermines emotional regulation—skills that are crucial for a child’s future well-being.

The Study: What You Need to Know

Conducted in Nova Scotia, Canada, the study followed 315 preschool-aged children from ages 3.5 to 5.5, examining their tablet use and emotional responses over time. What the researchers discovered is both eye-opening and thought-provoking: increased tablet use at age 3.5 was linked to heightened anger and frustration by age 4.5. But the story doesn’t end there—those very emotional outbursts at 4.5 years old were associated with even more tablet use by age 5.5.

The study’s design allowed researchers to observe these changes within the same child over time, effectively eliminating many of the usual variables that could skew such results. The findings reveal a potentially dangerous feedback loop: more screen time may lead to more frustration, which in turn may lead to even more screen time as a coping mechanism.

Why This Matters: The Cycle of Screen-Induced Anger

In our fast-paced, technology-driven world, tablets have become a staple in many households. They’re portable, engaging, and—let’s be honest—often a lifesaver for busy parents. But as this study suggests, the short-term relief these devices provide might come at a long-term cost.

Young children are at a crucial stage of developing emotional regulation skills. This is the ability to manage and respond to emotional experiences in a way that is socially acceptable and allows for healthy functioning. For preschoolers, learning how to navigate feelings of anger, frustration, and disappointment is a key part of their social and emotional development. When children spend too much time on screens, they may miss out on important opportunities to practice these skills in real-world situations.

Consider this analogy: learning to manage emotions is a bit like learning to ride a bike. It takes practice, falls, and a lot of encouragement to get it right. But what happens if a child spends most of their time on a screen instead of playing with others or engaging in imaginative play? They miss those essential “practice sessions,” which could leave them less equipped to handle their emotions as they grow.

Tablets as a Double-Edged Sword

One of the most striking aspects of the study is the bidirectional nature of the relationship between screen time and anger. It’s not just that tablet use leads to more frustration; children who are already prone to anger are also more likely to spend time on tablets. This creates a vicious cycle that can be difficult to break.

For many parents, handing over a tablet can feel like a quick fix during a meltdown. It’s easy to see why: screens can capture a child’s attention almost instantly, providing a momentary escape from the emotional storm. But this study suggests that relying on screens to manage behavior might only reinforce the very emotions we’re trying to calm.

Imagine a scenario where a child, frustrated after a long day, is given a tablet to help them unwind. The tablet may distract them temporarily, but it doesn’t teach them how to cope with their feelings. Instead, it might be reinforcing a pattern where screen time becomes the go-to solution for emotional distress. Over time, this could lead to a situation where the child struggles even more with emotional regulation, creating a cycle of frustration and screen dependency.

Breaking the Cycle: What Can Parents and Educators Do?

So, what can be done to counteract this cycle? The good news is that the study also highlights the malleability of these behaviors. Just as screen time can increase over time, it can also be reduced, and with it, the associated frustrations.

1. Limit Screen Time: One of the most straightforward strategies is to set clear boundaries around screen time. This might mean reserving tablets for specific situations, such as educational activities, rather than using them as a go-to distraction.
2. Encourage Non-Screen Activities: Promote activities that help children develop emotional regulation skills. Playtime with peers, outdoor activities, and creative play are all excellent ways to practice handling emotions in a supportive environment.
3. Model Healthy Screen Use: Children learn a lot by observing the adults around them. If they see parents and caregivers managing their own screen time and emotions effectively, they are more likely to mimic those behaviors.
4. Use Screens Wisely: Not all screen time is created equal. Some apps and programs are designed to support emotional development. For example, shows like Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood incorporate lessons on managing emotions, which can be beneficial when used mindfully.

A Call to Action for Parents and Educators

As we navigate the challenges of modern parenting, it’s crucial to remain aware of the potential impacts of screen time on our children’s emotional development. Tablets and other digital devices are here to stay, but how we choose to incorporate them into our children’s lives can make a significant difference.

The next time you’re tempted to hand over the tablet to soothe a fussy child, take a moment to consider alternative strategies. Could this be an opportunity to help your child practice handling their emotions in a different way? The small choices we make every day can have a big impact on our children’s ability to manage their emotions and navigate the world around them.

Final Thoughts

The study we’ve explored today offers valuable insights into the complex relationship between screen time and emotional regulation in young children. While tablets can be a helpful tool in moderation, it’s essential to be mindful of their potential to create cycles of frustration and dependency.

What do you think?

1. How do you balance screen time with other activities in your child’s daily routine?
2. What strategies have you found effective in helping your child develop emotional regulation skills without relying on screens?

If you found this blog helpful, please share it with other parents and educators in your network. Together, we can create a healthier, more balanced approach to screen time and emotional development for our children.

Join the Educational Revolution!

Begin your adventure with This Week in School Psychology for only $5 a month or $50 annually. Be at the forefront of educational breakthroughs and mental health insights. Subscribe to become a beacon of knowledge in your community, simplifying the complex world of educational research. Why wait? Ignite your passion for learning today and enjoy exclusive savings with our annual plan!